+- RomanArmyTalk (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat)
+-- Forum: Reenactment (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Roman Re-Enactment & Reconstruction (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+--- Thread: Does polyester has any harsh effects? (/showthread.php?tid=27077)
Does polyester has any harsh effects? - Ritika Sharma - 05-13-2016
Does polyester has any harsh effects as being uncomfortable in use?
RE: Does polyester has any harsh effects? - Crispianus - 05-13-2016
(05-13-2016, 07:58 AM)nagpal thread factory Wrote: Does polyester has any harsh effects as being uncomfortable in use?
I expect that most here would not use polyester regardless of whether it was comfortable or not, as its not a historical material for Roman clothing... linen(flax) or Cotton would be more appropriate...
RE: Does polyester has any harsh effects? - M. Val. Naso - 05-13-2016
Depends. If you are a stitch nazi, it'll burn your skin. If you're a farb, it will nicely help channel away the sweat it makes you break. There is no in between.
RE: Does polyester has any harsh effects? - Dan D'Silva - 05-13-2016
What I've always heard is that since polyester fibers are less porous than natural ones, they don't "breathe" or wick sweat away from the skin, which makes polyester clothing hot and sweaty in warm weather.
I've also heard of claims of "porous polyester" that does breathe like natural fiber, but I have no experience with it.
If you're planning on making reenactment clothing, I agree with Ivor. Reenactment groups and events generally require that participants wear only fabrics which are accurate for their time period, so polyester isn't acceptable for any pre-20th-century reenactments. It's arguably okay for historically-inspired fantasy clothing -- but that isn't our area of focus.
RE: Does polyester has any harsh effects? - Crispianus - 05-18-2016
(05-13-2016, 11:12 AM)M. Val. Naso Wrote: Depends. If you are a stitch nazi, it'll burn your skin. If you're a farb, it will nicely help channel away the sweat it makes you break. There is no in between.
I find it curious that the Vanilla reenactors have invented names for each other, a recent development I think... perhaps its something that fits together neatly with facebook accounts
RE: Does polyester has any harsh effects? - M. Val. Naso - 05-26-2016
Vanilla as in I'm so sweet?
But totally depends. Would you consider an 80 or 90% wool totally inauthentic? I've seen many people use it in Hungary, even guys with high self-esteem, since most of the time a proper meter of 100% wool can cost 25-30 euros, which may not be much, but the Hungarian average net salary is below 500...
RE: Does polyester has any harsh effects? - Crispianus - 05-27-2016
(05-26-2016, 03:24 PM)M. Val. Naso Wrote: Vanilla as in I'm so sweet?
But totally depends. Would you consider an 80 or 90% wool totally inauthentic? I've seen many people use it in Hungary, even guys with high self-esteem, since most of the time a proper meter of 100% wool can cost 25-30 euros, which may not be much, but the Hungarian average net salary is below 500...
As in ordinary....
As to cloth thats up to you and your group rules if you have any, my main reason for not using artificial fibres other then the practical and accuracy reasons for clothing is the fire risk...
Any cloth not made from 100% natural fibres would of course not be accurate but then you'd also have to consider:
Weave, Colour and the dye method, Machine verses hand weaving and spinning, stitching etc...
Most will stop at wool etc in a reasonable colour so you might say thats the bench mark, its clear though that when you consider everything that not many reinactors are going to be walking around in authentic clothing, the best you can expect is they look like their walking around in authentic clothing... which is fair enough.
The cost thing has been around since reenactment began... My advice would be get the best natural cloth you can afford in a reasonable weave and colour thats fit for purpose and hand stitch it together....
RE: Does polyester has any harsh effects? - Ritika Sharma - 07-07-2016
thanks for the reply.
RE: Does polyester has any harsh effects? - Fabricius Carbo - 07-07-2016
I would say a 70/30 wool/polyester mix is indistinguishable from all wool and will wear and wash far better than all wool.