Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Did the Romans love Garum because of the MSG?
#1
This from the Sci-Fi & Science web site IO9:

http://io9.com/?utm_source=io9+Newslette...s-made-msg

How the ancient Romans made MSG Esther Inglis-Arkell — Monosodium glutamate is a food additive that enhances flavor. Although it's frowned upon today, the ancient Romans loved it and ate it with almost every meal.

There's been some debate over what exactly monosodium glutamate does to people. Some people say it gives them severe headaches, numbness, weakness, and even heart palpitations. Scientists could confirm that it does give some people short-lived reactions, but no tests showed that it had long-term health effects. Some say that it's an addictive substance which causes people to crave it repeatedly if they try it too often. Others say it's just a flavor enhancer, and people crave it because it makes things taste better.


The chemical is listed as 'safe' by the FDA, although they do require it to be clearly listed as an additive in any food product that uses it. It's most often found in canned soups and vegetables. Modern MSG is manufactured using genetically engineered bacteria. They take in nutrients and excrete glutamic acid. The acid is concentrated, and sodium is added to make the final product.

The process sounds very modern, but MSG has been around for a very long time. It was a common food additive during the time of ancient Rome, added to almost all Roman dishes. The Romans had a lot of technology for their time, but they couldn't genetically engineer bacteria. So how did they come up with MSG? Believe it or not, they used an even more disgusting process than bacteria excretions. The Romans had a fish paste called garum that they exported everywhere. They made it by filling pots with alternating layers of fish - or just fish guts - and salt and letting those pots lie out in the sun for a while.

As the mixture lay out in the sun, the stomach acids for the fish ate through their bodies. They eventually broke down the entire fish, turning the whole thing into a dark brown oily goo. When protein is broken down, the amino acid chains in the protein are freed up. One of these acid chains contains glutamic acid, which meets up with sodium from the salt and forms MSG. The Romans were such fans of the flavor enhancer that they even put it in sweets like custard. They also died off in droves, so anyone who wishes to recreate garum Roman-style — don't do it. Try organizing gladiator-style games in the back yard as a safer alternative.

Via Truth in Labeling, The Mayo Clinic, and About.com.


I don't buy into the concluding paragraph. In fact this article will probably be used by some enterprising "historian" as proof that the roman Empire fell because of too much MSG in the Roman diet.

MSG in the food, lead in the water, barbarians at the gate, homosexuality in the bedroom ... It's a wonder the romans ever had an empire at all ... Confusedhock: :? :roll:

:wink:

Narukami
David Reinke
Burbank CA
Reply
#2
I find this information interesting enough, even without the Roman Empire falling for it... :roll:
At least it would explain the Roman love for that garum, if it is true.
------------
[Image: regnumhesperium.png]
Reply
#3
Interesting theory - about the Romans' love of garum because of MSG, that is.

It's a shame that the author didn't finish with a more grounded statement such as 'Too much MSG can be very harmful. It is possible that at a time of low life expectancy, many Romans may have died from its harmful effects.'

Thanks for posting, Narukami.
Ben Kane, bestselling author of the Eagles of Rome, Spartacus and Hannibal novels.

Eagles in the Storm released in UK on March 23, 2017.
Aguilas en la tormenta saldra en 2017.


www.benkane.net
Twitter: @benkaneauthor
Facebook: facebook.com/benkanebooks
Reply
#4
How about thinking that Garum was used like salt?
Ever tried some of those Thai fish sauces, which are made on a very simular basis like garum?
All this MSG and other chemical additives are so called "blessings" of our modern food industries. Now all we need is some one to find roman aquivilants to those substances marked as E-100 or E-140 etc. On the other hand why should the romans have given that any thought as stuff like MSG was unknown to them......ancient people certainly would not have a modern approach on things, which we know of in detail because of research in the last few centuries. On that basis one could ask what where the roman thoughts on aluminium.....
Reply


Forum Jump: