Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Printable Version +- RomanArmyTalk (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat) +-- Forum: Research Arena (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Forum: References & Reviews (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat/forumdisplay.php?fid=13) +--- Thread: Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi (/showthread.php?tid=22065) Pages:
1
2
|
Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - jho - 02-01-2013 Salvete! Mr. Pitassi appears to have published a number of books on the Roman navy over the last two years: The Roman Navy: Ships, Men & Warfare 350BC - AD475 The Navies of Rome Roman Warships Reviews I have found on the internet appear to be somewhat reserved. Before I spend my whole 2013 book budget on these titles, I would be grateful if somebody who has read them could comment on their quality. Thank you! Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Michael Kerr - 02-01-2013 Hi Jens, sorry I can't help you in regards to the three Michael Pitassi books you listed but I have 2 books by Lionel Casson which although he writes about ancient seafarers, he includes the Roman Navy as well as Byzantines,Greeks and Phoenicians. You may already have them but the 2 books I have are "The Ancient Mariners" by Lionel Casson "Ships and Seamanship in the Ancient World" by Lionel Casson The only other book I have about the Roman Navy is "Roman Britain and the Roman Navy by David J.P. Mason. The best of the 2 Casson books to me is "Ships and Seamanship in the Ancient World" it is 592 pages in length and covers warships,merchant ships and sailing ships, crews, markings and names, harbours plus many other aspects of ancient naval history. Regards Michael Kerr Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Quintus Aurelius Lepidus - 02-01-2013 Yeah like the books about casson too. :-) Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - jho - 02-04-2013 Thank you for the responses. I have the Casson books and also like them. Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Praefectusclassis - 02-04-2013 Hi Jens Let's say that I don't agree with his interpretation of the Roman navy. :whistle: Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Quintus Aurelius Lepidus - 02-04-2013 I think the book of chester starr good one too. http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Roman-Imperial-Navy-B-C-A-D-324/dp/0890055440/ref=ntt_at_ep_dpt_10 it is a pretty old one though. (i thought written in the 40's but i could be mistaken) Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Quintus Aurelius Lepidus - 02-04-2013 and don't worry about the price, i bought it much much cheaper too :p Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Quintus Aurelius Lepidus - 02-04-2013 Jasper, do you have any other good titles ? Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Roberto Romani - 02-05-2013 I'm halfway of Pitassi's "The navies of Rome" and it isn't bad IMHO. But I haven't read anything by Casson, so, I can't make comparison. Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Gatorsailor - 02-06-2013 Books on the Roman Navy are indeed hard to find. A list of known books would be nice! Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Praefectusclassis - 02-06-2013 It's really very short: there's Starr's book, the two books by Thiel on the Republican fleets (good luck finding those outside a uni library), Christa Steinby's recent book on the early Roman fleets, Mason's on the Classis Britannica and Pitassi's slew of ... Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Vindex - 02-07-2013 Thiel (not cheap) http://www.abebooks.co.uk/servlet/SearchResults?an=Thiel&bt.x=38&bt.y=14&kn=Republican+fleet&sts=t Abe have a .com address as well as a .co.uk so you never know your luck! Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Renatus - 02-07-2013 There is a slightly cheaper copy here: http://www.en.zvab.com/displayBookDetails.do?itemId=204285479&ref=bf and his other book is here: http://www.booksatpbfa.com/search/results.php?item_id=1035893880 Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Nathan Ross - 02-07-2013 Quote:Pitassi's slew of ... What's the problem with his interpretation, do you think? (if that wouldn't require too long an answer!) Books on Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi - Praefectusclassis - 02-07-2013 I can keep the answer very short: he attributes very modern properties to the Roman naval forces. This in fact something most modern books about ancient naval warfare are guilty of. The problem is that 'we' (ie anyone in the modern western world and especially those of us from traditionally maritime nations such as the UK, US and NL) are so ingrained with these notions it takes a special effort to consciously turn them off. That and Pitassi's horribly annoying habit of 'semi accurate' annotation where he points to entire books if you're lucky and doesn't use notes at all when it gets interesting. |