10-11-2011, 11:26 AM
Firstly, use of guy ropes is not incompatible with this alternative way of holding up the central ridge, as they could be used to create the "wall"- either with or without internal support poles/ furcas.
Secondly, this method would be both more stable and simple to put up. The poles could be locally sourced, transported on the mule or even - as a possibility- using spare hasta.
Thirdly, it is compatible with other Roman tent depictions outside Trajans column- I am unaware of any wall tent depictions with a central pole. There are several " dog tent " depictions with a central pole however in Late sources.
Finally, I don't think this is not a question of "make your mind up", but of debating alternatives to see what could or would work, based around the evidence, both material and iconographic, including Trajan's Column.
Secondly, this method would be both more stable and simple to put up. The poles could be locally sourced, transported on the mule or even - as a possibility- using spare hasta.
Thirdly, it is compatible with other Roman tent depictions outside Trajans column- I am unaware of any wall tent depictions with a central pole. There are several " dog tent " depictions with a central pole however in Late sources.
Finally, I don't think this is not a question of "make your mind up", but of debating alternatives to see what could or would work, based around the evidence, both material and iconographic, including Trajan's Column.