03-02-2012, 03:48 AM
@Tom, @Christian
If you want an idealistic affair thoroughly ruined -- let the marketing people take over !
@Christian : I faintly remember that Troja "affair" -- wasn't the an open letter by some Tübingian scholars about 7-8 years back that went to greater recognition through the internet ?
It seems some aspects "behaviour" you criticise has become more prominent in science of all
sorts. Plagiarism, falsification etc etc , but seriously, this has happend before and
it's likely to happen again. :roll:
But I'm really happy that discussion on Kalkriese seems to have opened up.
A quick glance over the link you posted:
http://www.clades-variana.com/beurteilun...kriese.htm
...showed interesting views, points and aspects, but one or two things become moot
if you doubt the correct reconstruction at the Kalkriese site. :wink:
(I won't go into discussion about the "earth walls " unless this is requested here.)
Thanks and good night so far.
Greez
Simplex
If you want an idealistic affair thoroughly ruined -- let the marketing people take over !
@Christian : I faintly remember that Troja "affair" -- wasn't the an open letter by some Tübingian scholars about 7-8 years back that went to greater recognition through the internet ?
It seems some aspects "behaviour" you criticise has become more prominent in science of all
sorts. Plagiarism, falsification etc etc , but seriously, this has happend before and
it's likely to happen again. :roll:
But I'm really happy that discussion on Kalkriese seems to have opened up.
A quick glance over the link you posted:
http://www.clades-variana.com/beurteilun...kriese.htm
...showed interesting views, points and aspects, but one or two things become moot
if you doubt the correct reconstruction at the Kalkriese site. :wink:
(I won't go into discussion about the "earth walls " unless this is requested here.)
Thanks and good night so far.
Greez
Simplex
Siggi K.
