Boeotian/Dipylon Shield

[Chris B]

Paul, even with dowling the rings, using that method leaves the Boeotian weaker than the Aspis. Think about this, the thinnest part of the shield (maybe a half inch at best) is the only thing holding the two heavier halves together. The rim is what makes the Aspis stronger because all the weight and force is distributed towards the outside circumference of the shield. If it was covered in Bronze, I think it would be a bit stronger, but it would NEVER be as strong as leaving the rim completely intact (can't beat physics). As for the Roman Legion Quarter Master shields.....I don't think they make Boeotian shields. I saw the metal Aspis. I most definately think it would be stronger for simulated combat than a wooden core, hide covered shield, but the Aspis is quite a bit stronger than the Boeotian using the ring method. I think it would hold up ok. I personally would rather have a metal version that I would not mind getting dinged and scratched after spending hours and hours making this one as perfect as possible. On the shield in progress.....I have finished the face completely and it looks good. I only have the back rim to paint now. It will probably take 48 more hours to be complete as the back of the rim will be two colors, and I have to wait for them to dry.