+- RomanArmyTalk (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat)
+-- Forum: Research Arena (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Roman Military History & Archaeology (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat/forumdisplay.php?fid=8)
+--- Thread: Roman weapons and culture and Hindus weapons (/showthread.php?tid=23926)
Roman weapons and culture and Hindus weapons - SAJID - 12-26-2014
Hi,
I did notice that Roman weapons and culture is mostly same like
early Hindus weapons and culture what is the reason?
please provide me solution if possible.
with best regards-sajid
Roman weapons and culture and Hindus weapons - Urselius - 12-26-2014
The same reason that Dyaus-pita meant "Sky-father" in Sanskrit and Jiu-piter was the sky god of Rome - a shared Indo-European background.
Roman weapons and culture and Hindus weapons - Dan D'Silva - 12-27-2014
I'm not sure I'd attribute it to that. Proto-Indo-European fragmented long before a distinct Roman culture emerged, so I'd think that more often than not, similarities would be due to convergent evolution or cultural diffusion via the Near East.
Sajid, could you give some examples and we could discuss them more specifically?
Roman weapons and culture and Hindus weapons - SAJID - 12-27-2014
Hi,
Early Hindus used to swords,archery, knives like these type weapons and wearing torque,
their dresses like roman culture also but in weapons their shape and size different.
regards-sajid
Roman weapons and culture and Hindus weapons - Urselius - 12-27-2014
I was mostly referring to culture, as I do not think that the military technology was all that similar. Other than the fact that all swords are sharpened lengths of metal with a handle. At the time of Alexander the Great's invasion of India the Indians used broadswords and long-bows more similar to 14th century English than contemporary Greco-Roman weapons.
Roman weapons and culture and Hindus weapons - Youngster - 12-27-2014
I'm not familiar with Indian arms contemporary to the Roman republic/empire. I'd be much obliged if you would post some examples so we could compare specific pieces. I haven't had luck finding "romanesque" Indian arms via google search.
Roman weapons and culture and Hindus weapons - Walhaz - 12-29-2014
I would also like some specific examples of similarities. A look at my coffee-table copy of Lord Egerton's Indian and Oriental Arms and Armour reveals swords like the khanda (a chopping, not a stabbing weapon) and missile weapons like the chakram. I'm certain they had the near-ubiquitous spear and bow, but what armaments did you mean specifically, Sajid?
Roman weapons and culture and Hindus weapons - daryush - 01-01-2015
The only thing that comes t mind is the scabbard slide, which in some older books is described as a Roman scabbard - written before Trousdale's work on scabbard slides, or citing works written before Trousdale's. The scabbard slide in India has a Central Asian origin via the Kushans or Sakas though, so that's not really an item anymore. Some similarities between Indian axes and MUCH later Byzantine axes are due to designs migrating west with the Silk Route / Eurasian nomadic movements. The helmet from Taxila is the same as Trajan's column helmet, and Tepe Yahya helmet, and again due to a common Saka ancestor. Forward curving swords which appear in the Sunga or late Mauryan era *may* have Greek origins, but the hilt and blade geometry even at this early stage is considerably different from Hellenisitic types.